Skip to Content
Categories:

5 More Underrated Horror Movies to Watch This Halloween

Artwork featuring the 5 films listed in this article, covered by Halloween-styled text which reads, “5 More Underrated Horror Movies to Watch this Halloween.” (Jonathan Castle)

Last year, the Oakdale Post put together a list of 5 underrated horror movies recommended by students. This year, students at Oakdale have assembled this list of 5 more underrated horror films, just in time for you to watch over Halloween. Now, let’s get spooky!

Star Jaime Vadell as Augusto Pinochet in a fittingly gothic, black & white still from the 2023 film El Conde, shot by Ed Lachman.
El Conde (2023)

Acclaimed filmmaker Pablo Larrian’s newest film, El Conde, satirizes Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet by portraying him as an immortal vampire, desperately (and bloodily) holding on to his power. It’s a funny, terse, dark work of political cinema with a powerful sense of visual language and cultural relevance. 

 

Exclusively streaming on Netflix.

Star Jaime Vadell as Augusto Pinochet in a fittingly gothic, black & white still from the 2023 film El Conde, shot by Ed Lachman. (Director Pablo Larrian; Director of Photography Ed Lachman; Photo via TMDB)
Lee (Timothee Chalamet) and Maren (Taylor Russell) are seen together somewhere in the plains of the Midwest in a still from the 2022 film Bones & All.
Bones and All (2022)

This horror-romance, brought to life through terrific performances by Timothee Chalamet and Taylor Russell, is a beautiful testament to the power of young love. From director Luca Guadagnino (Suspira [2018], Call Me By Your Name [2017], etc.), it follows Maren Yearly (Russell), whose  cannibalistic tendencies force her to split town. Searching for her mother, she encounters Sully (Mark Rylance), who makes her realize that she’s not the only one. She meets Lee (Chalamet), and the romance blossoms from there. It’s a great film; just watch out for the sequence that takes place in Frederick. 

 

Available to stream on Amazon Prime Video and to rent or buy wherever you rent or buy movies.

Lee (Timothee Chalamet) and Maren (Taylor Russell) are seen together somewhere in the plains of the Midwest in a still from the 2022 film Bones & All. (Director Luca Guadagnino, Director of Photography Arseni Khachaturan. Photo via TMDB.)
Promotional artwork for Totally Killer featuring Kiernan Shipka’s time-traveling heroine and the “Sweet 16 Killer.”
Totally Killer (2023)

This new horror-comedy was released at the start of October, but it flew under the radar, which is disappointing because it’s one of the wittiest additions to the genre recently. It stars Kiernan Shipka (Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) as Jamie Hughes, a typical teenager in a typical town in 2023—except for two murders back in 1987. When the killer strikes again, Jamie accidentally  travels back in time and must solve the killings. Using slasher cliches to deconstruct the genre’s recent obsession with ‘80s nostalgia, Totally Killer is one of the most startlingly original horror comedies of late. 

 

Exclusively streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

Promotional artwork for Totally Killer featuring Kiernan Shipka’s time-traveling heroine and the “Sweet 16 Killer.” (Director Nahnatchka Khan, Director of Photography Judd Overton. Photo via TMDB.)
Actress Kate Siegel as deaf writer Maddie, seen in a still from Mike Flannagan’s 2016 film, Hush.
Hush (2016)

Junior Xaver Alexander recommends this 2016 film from acclaimed Haunting of Hill House director Mike Flannagan. “[It follows] a deaf author [who] lives in a secluded house in the woods,” Alexander explained, “[and] she must fight [for] her life when a masked killer appears.” It’s a simple premise, as Alexander admits, but it offers an interesting perspective: “The fact that she’s deaf [is unique]. [Few other horror movies] have a deaf lead, so [so few have] that set of obstacles [for] characters to face.”

Actress Kate Siegel as deaf writer Maddie, seen in a still from Mike Flannagan’s 2016 film, Hush. (Director Mike Flannagan, Director of Photography James Kniest; photo via TMDB)
A piece of promotional artwork featuring work from the Shout! Factory collector’s edition Blu-Ray.
The Exorcist III (1990)

Everyone knows director William Friedken and writer William Peter Blatty’s 1973 masterpiece, The Exorcist, but most will not know about Blatty’s 1990 follow-up, The Exorcist III. “[It] starts out with the original police lieutenant,” Junior Noah Day summarized, “[played by] one of my favorite actors, George C. Scott, it follows his journey through solving a mysterious string of ‘copycat’ murders.” Day continued: “I like how the movie takes a different path from the rest of the Exorcist movies. [It’s an intense movie that gives the audience] a good scare.”

Currently streaming on Shudder, AMC+, Amazon Prime Video, Peacock, and the Criterion Channel in their “‘90s Horror” feature. It’s also available to rent or buy wherever you rent or buy movies.

A piece of promotional artwork featuring work from the Shout! Factory collector’s edition Blu-Ray. (Director William Peter Blatty, Director of Photography Gerry Fisher; Photo via TMDB)
Donate to The Oakdale Post
$150
$400
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Oakdale High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
Donate to The Oakdale Post
$150
$400
Contributed
Our Goal